Kyle Andrews, MD Call 419-291-3858

Clicking or clunking after knee replacement

Most clicking after a knee replacement is harmless: metal and plastic touching as the knee moves. A clunk, a catch, or clicking that comes with pain, swelling or giving way is different.

The short answer

Painless clicking is common and usually needs no treatment. Clicking that comes with pain, swelling, a catching feeling, or a knee that gives way should be checked.

Usually normal

A soft click or tap when you bend and straighten the knee, with no pain. It is often more noticeable in the first months, while the muscles around the knee are still weak, and it often fades as the leg gets stronger.

Worth having checked

A clunk when straightening the knee

Scar tissue can form just above the kneecap and catch on the implant, then release with a clunk as the knee straightens. It is often treatable with a small procedure.

Signs that point here: a catch or clunk when you straighten from a bent position, such as getting up from a chair.

Instability

A knee that is too loose can click or clunk as the parts shift, and often swells.

Signs that point here: clicking along with swelling and a knee that gives way or feels wobbly.

Kneecap tracking

Pain at the front of the knee or around the kneecap that has been there since surgery, sometimes with stiffness, can come from the kneecap not tracking straight because of how the implant parts are rotated. Special imaging can measure that rotation.

Signs that point here: front-of-knee or kneecap pain since your surgery, sometimes with stiffness.

Wear

After 10 or more years, worn plastic can make the knee grind or clunk.

Signs that point here: a replacement more than 10 years old, grinding, swelling.

What an evaluation looks like

I start with your story and an exam, then take new X-rays and compare them with older ones whenever we can get them. Blood tests check for infection, and sometimes fluid is drawn from the joint with a needle and tested. Bring any CT or MRI scans from the last few years. Revision surgery is recommended only when we know what it would fix.

I see patients at ProMedica Toledo Hospital on Mondays and ProMedica Flower Hospital in Sylvania on Wednesdays. Patients also travel from across northwest Ohio and southeast Michigan for revision care.

Not sure what's going on? The 2-minute self-check asks about your symptoms and explains what could be causing them. Nothing you enter is saved.

Take the self-check

Sources

This page is general education, written for patients. It draws on these guidelines and studies, alongside my own clinical practice.

  1. Hedeman M, et al. Patellar Clunk Syndrome: A Systematic Review of Risk Factors and Treatment. Arthroplasty Today. 2026;37. View source

Ready to be seen?

New appointments are made by phone. One number books both offices.

Call 419-291-3858 Locations and parking

Call 419-291-3858