Kyle Andrews, MD Main site Call 419-291-3858

Painful knee or hip replacement

Still hurting after your knee or hip replacement?

Most people feel much better within a year of a joint replacement. If you don't, or if a replacement that felt great for years has started to hurt, you're not imagining it, and you don't have to just live with it. There is usually a reason, and it can usually be found.

Pain after a replacement has a cause

Revision surgery, fixing or redoing a joint replacement, is a large part of my practice. These are the most common reasons a replacement hurts. Some show up clearly on X-rays. Others need blood tests, a closer exam or special imaging to find.

Infection

Bacteria on the implant can cause pain, swelling and warmth, sometimes years after surgery. It doesn't always cause a fever, which is why it gets missed.

Loosening

An implant that was solidly fixed to the bone can come loose over time. A classic sign is pain with your first steps after sitting.

Instability

A knee that gives way or feels wobbly, or a hip that feels like it slips or has dislocated. Often comes with swelling that keeps coming back.

Stiffness

A knee that never got its bend or straightening back, even with hard work in therapy.

Wear

After 10 or more years, the plastic liner can wear down, causing pain, swelling or grinding.

Metal-on-metal hips

Some older hips used a metal ball in a metal socket. They can shed metal debris that irritates the tissues around the joint, sometimes with few symptoms.

Pain from somewhere else

The back, nerves, tendons and circulation can all cause pain that feels like it's coming from the replaced joint. Sorting this out is part of a good evaluation.

Two-minute self-check

Answer nine quick questions to see whether a painful joint replacement evaluation makes sense for you. This is a guide, not a diagnosis.

Private by design. Your answers stay on your device. Nothing is saved or sent to anyone, and we never ask for your name. At the end you can print or copy a summary to bring to your appointment.
1.Do you have any of these right now?

Check all that apply.

2.Which joint hurts?
3.How long ago was your replacement?
4.Which sounds most like your pain?
5.Where does it hurt most?

Choose your joint in question 2 first.

6.When is it worst?

Check all that apply.

7.Do any of these describe your joint?

Check all that apply.

8.On a typical day, how bad is the pain?

0 is no pain. 10 is the worst pain you can imagine.

9.Has anyone looked into this pain yet?

What a painful joint replacement evaluation looks like

The goal of the first visit is an answer, not a sales pitch for surgery. Many patients leave with a plan that doesn't involve an operation.

  1. Your story

    When the pain started, what it feels like, what makes it worse, and anything that happened around your original surgery.

  2. A careful exam

    Of the replaced joint and the areas that can mimic its pain, like the back and the hip or knee above and below.

  3. New X-rays

    Compared side by side with your older films whenever we can get them, along with any CT or MRI you've had in the last few years. Small changes over time often tell the story.

  4. Testing for infection

    Usually simple blood tests. Sometimes fluid is drawn from the joint with a needle, because infection must be ruled out before anything else is decided.

  5. A clear plan

    Sometimes more imaging, sometimes therapy or treatment for another source of pain, and sometimes revision surgery. Either way, you'll know what's going on.

"Could I be allergic to my implant?"

It's one of the questions I'm asked most often.

Many people have a skin allergy to metals like nickel, and most of them do perfectly well with a joint replacement. A true allergic reaction deep in the tissues around an implant is very rare, and doctors still debate how often it happens and how best to test for it. Skin patch tests don't reliably predict it.

Because of that, metal allergy is usually considered only after the common causes, like infection, loosening and instability, have been checked. If you have a known metal allergy, or you're worried about one, bring it up at your visit.

Coming from out of town?

Patients travel to Toledo for revision care. Sending your records ahead lets us make your first visit count.

What helps most

  • The operative note from each surgery on that joint
  • The implant record (the sticker sheet listing each part)
  • Your X-ray images on a disc, not only the written reports
  • Any CT or MRI scans from the last few years, with the images and reports
  • Any lab results or joint fluid tests, and recent therapy notes

How to send them

Ask your previous surgeon's office to fax records to 419-480-8701, or sign a records release at their office and have them sent to us.

Bring your imaging discs to your first visit, or call 419-291-3858 and we'll tell you how to get images to us ahead of time.

Please don't email medical records or post them online.

For physical therapists and referring doctors

If your patient's knee or hip replacement isn't progressing the way it should, I'm happy to see them. An early look is better than a late one.

Good reasons to refer

Pain or stiffness that has plateaued in therapy, recurrent swelling, instability, start-up pain, a replacement that hurts again after years of doing well, or any concern for infection.

How to refer

Fax a referral to 419-480-8701 with recent notes, or have the patient call 419-291-3858 and ask for a painful joint replacement evaluation. Recent X-rays, and any CT or MRI from the last few years, are helpful but not required.

Make an appointment

Call the office and ask for a painful joint replacement evaluation.

419-291-3858

New appointments are made by phone. Already a patient? Message us on MyChart.

Where I see patients

Mondays: ProMedica Toledo Hospital, Harris McIntosh Tower, 2121 Hughes Dr, Suite 310, Toledo

Wednesdays: ProMedica Flower Hospital, 5300 Harroun Rd, Suite 118, Sylvania

Parking and directions

Sources

This page is general education, written for patients. It draws on these guidelines and studies, alongside my own clinical practice.

  1. Parvizi J, et al. The 2018 Definition of Periprosthetic Hip and Knee Infection: An Evidence-Based and Validated Criteria. J Arthroplasty. 2018. View source
  2. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Clinical Practice Guideline on the Diagnosis and Prevention of Periprosthetic Joint Infections. 2019. View source
  3. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Metal-on-Metal Hip Implants: Information for Patients. View source
  4. Hedeman M, et al. Patellar Clunk Syndrome: A Systematic Review of Risk Factors and Treatment. Arthroplasty Today. 2026;37. View source
Call 419-291-3858